Oil vs gas boiler in rural Somerset — which one wins?

If your home isn't on mains gas — very common across the Mendips, Chew Valley and villages around Radstock — this is the honest comparison you actually need.

Mains gas

Cheapest fuel per kWh, no on-site storage, most efficient modern combis. Only works if the gas main reaches your street.

Oil (kerosene)

The default for off-grid Somerset homes. Higher per-kWh cost, needs a bunded tank, but reliable and well-supported locally.

Running cost comparison (2026)

FuelTypical cost / kWhAnnual cost, 3-bed home (~12,000 kWh)
Mains gas~6.5 p~£780
Heating oil (kerosene)~7.5 p~£900
LPG~10 p~£1,200
Air-source heat pump (COP 3)~9 p effective~£1,080

Prices vary with market conditions; oil in particular fluctuates seasonally. Buying oil in summer typically saves 8–15%.

When oil is the right choice

  • • Your street has no mains gas and the nearest connection would cost more than £3–5k to run in.
  • • You have — or can install — an OFTEC-compliant bunded tank at least 1.8m from the property, 760mm from a boundary.
  • • Your home is well insulated (heat pumps struggle in solid-wall stone cottages without upgrades).
  • • You want a single fuel source that heats water on demand as well as central heating.

When to consider switching

  • Oil → mains gas: only worth it if gas is within ~30m of the meter position. Ask the DNO for a connection quote first.
  • Oil → LPG: rarely a good move on cost alone — usually chosen for aesthetics (no tank) or a gas hob.
  • Oil → heat pump: best paired with insulation upgrades and larger radiators. BUS grant of £7,500 makes this viable for many rural homes.

Oil tank rules you should know

  • Bunded (double-skinned) tanks are mandatory for domestic installs since 2001.
  • • Position: 1.8m from any building opening (window/door), 760mm from a boundary, 600mm from non-fire-rated eaves.
  • • Base: 100mm concrete or paving slabs, extending 300mm beyond the tank on all sides.
  • • Fire valve required at the appliance end of the fuel line.
  • • Installations must be certified by an OFTEC engineer (like us) to satisfy Building Regs.

Local reality check

Across BA3 (Radstock), BS39 (Paulton) and BS40 (Chew Valley) roughly 30–40% of properties we quote are off mains gas. In most cases a modern condensing oil boiler (Worcester Greenstar Heatslave or Grant Vortex Blue) is still the most cost-effective replacement — often £3,400–£4,600 supplied and fitted vs £8k+ for a heat pump before grants.

Related reading

Not sure which is best for your home?

Free site survey — we'll check gas availability, tank placement and give you a like-for-like comparison in writing.

Worcester Bosch Accredited · 10 Year Guarantee*

New Worcester boiler with a 10 year guarantee*

Free no-obligation quotes for installation, servicing & repairs across BA & BS postcodes.

Call Now Get Quote